Concept of Inchoate crimes

Inchoate crimes are unfinished crimes, the crimes which couldn’t able to get completed due to some reason or were disrupted in between by anyone, intentionally or unintentionally, resulting in not the completion of the offence. Inchoate has come from the Latin word- ‘Inchoate’ means ‘begun’. The word ‘inchoate’ literally means ‘underdeveloped’ or ‘unfinished’ and the term, “inchoate offence” refers to acts engaged towards the commission of a criminal act, or which amount to indirect participation in a criminal act. It simply means the offences which are incomplete and it signifies the acts which are just close to the commission of the offence.

For example: A plan to murder Z, and arrange a gun to do the same, A reaches Z’s house and points the gun towards Z with full intention to kill Z but by mistake miss the short, in this case scenario, the murder had not committed so A will not get any charges for murder but definitely going to get punishment for attempt to murder.

Under criminal law, there are four stages of the commission of any crime:

Formation of a mental element or mens rea.
Preparation for the commission of the crime.
Acting on the basis of such preparation.
Commission of the act resulting in an event punishable by law.

Out of these four stages normally the liability under law exists in the third and the fourth stages only, and the accused is not guilty if his act falls under the first or the second stage. i.e., under the mental stage and the preparatory stage. For example: if A wants to kill B but does not do anything further in this regard he still being in the mental stage is not guilty of any crime. With such intention, if he buys a revolver and gets a license for the same, even then he does not commit a crime because he is still in the preparatory stage.

According to Section 511 of the IPC, only half of the punishment is awarded because the injury is not as great as if that crime had been committed. The two elements mens rea and actus reus, are always necessary to constitute a crime. Where there is only mens rea there is no crime. Though actus reus is necessary to constitute a crime, yet there may be a crime even where those of actus reus that were intended have not been consummated. For example, A shoots at B, but misses the aim, no actus reus is consummated and so there is no murder, however, a crime has been committed. Liability begins only at a stage when the offender has done some act that not only manifests his mens rea but also goes some way carrying it out. These are known as inchoate crimes. Here, the crime is not taken quite serious as the final crime had not committed only the attempt had happened, that’s why the punishment of the same is not harsh as that of a real final crime. As for the instance, the punishment of murder under section 302 IPC is more strict as that of an attempt to murder in section 307 IPC.

Types of inchoate crimes

Inchoate crimes in the beginning had only one crime under its head, that being the offence of attempt. However, gradually there arose to be any further additions to the number of inchoate offences. The offences of abetment, conspiracy, and incitement have joint attempts under this head.

Abetment

The process of getting offence done by another person rather than himself. The offence of abatement is committed when a person does not commit the crime he wishes to commit by himself but urges or persuades another to commit the act. In order for the act committed to be abetment, one must merely provide support, command, or order another to commit the act and must not be the one to commit it himself. Laws relating to the definition of the crime, punishment duration, and other particulars are mentioned in Sections 107-120 in Chapter V of the Indian Penal Code. For example, A assists or aids B in the murder of C. B, as instigated form A, committed the crime of murder, then A is liable for abetment.

2. Attempt

Attempt refers to a type of inchoate crime where an individual intends to commit a target crime, An attempt has not been defined directly in the Indian Penal Code,1860. However, chapter XXIII of the IPC mentions the punishment to attempt an offence with imprisonment or life imprisonment as the case may be. From this definition, an attempt has the following key elements:

Intent to commit a crime. There needs to be proof the individual intended to commit the target offense. Therefore, accidental attempts are not viable in a court of law. Furthermore, the ulterior motive must be specific to the target crime and not a general ulterior motive without a particular intended outcome. Motives like recklessness are therefore insufficient evidence.
In some cases, they are treated as separate offences and thus are punished accordingly. For example, Attempt to Murder under Section 307, Attempt to Culpable Homicide under Section 308, and Attempt to Suicide under Section 309.

For example, in State v. Lyerla, a 1988 South Dakota case, a defendant fired shots into a truck carrying a driver and two passengers, killing the driver. The defendant was found guilty of “reckless” second-degree murder of the driver and was initially found guilty of attempted murder of the other passengers. However, the South Dakota Supreme Court held that a conviction of attempted murder was precluded because an attempt requires a higher level of intent than recklessness. The court noted that “to attempt to commit a crime, there must exist in the mind of the perpetrator the specific intent to commit the acts constituting the offence. To attempt second degree murder, one must intend to have a criminally reckless state of mind a logical impossibility.”

3. Conspiracy

A conspiracy is an agreement between two or more people to engage in unlawful conduct or commit a criminal act. Conspiracy is an inchoate crime because it does not require that the illegal act actually have been completed. For instance, a group of individuals can be convicted of conspiracy to commit burglary even if the actual burglary never happens. Conspiracy is also unique in that, unlike attempt, a defendant can be charged with both conspiracy to commit a crime, and the crime itself if the crime is completed.

For example: joe and Sam agree to poison their roommate, William. Joe purchases the poison and Sam coats a steak with the poison and places it on William’s dinner plate. William says he’s not hungry and doesn’t eat the poisoned steak. If Joe and Sam are in a jurisdiction without an overt act requirement, they are guilty of conspiracy at the moment they agree to poison their roommate. If an overt act is required, Joe purchasing the poison was certainly an overt act in furtherance of the conspiracy. Thus, both were guilty of conspiracy to commit murder when Joe bought the poison. “Attempted” murder probably didn’t crystalize until Sam put the poisoned steak on William’s plate, or at least until he coated the steak with poison.

4. Solicitation

Solicitation is a type of inchoate crime whereby an individual knowingly enlists another individual or individuals to aid them in committing a target offense. It is categorized as a felony or misdemeanor depending on the severity of the target crime. Furthermore, punishments for solicitation are typically proportionally lesser than punishments for the target crime.

Defenses to solicitation often include:

That the solicitor did not solicit the individual.
That the solicitor did not intend to commit the target crime.
In some cases, the solicitor recanted their intention to commit the target crime.

Reference

Aishwarya Says:

I have always been against Glorifying Over Work and therefore, in the year 2021, I have decided to launch this campaign “Balancing Life”and talk about this wrong practice, that we have been following since last few years. I will be talking to and interviewing around 1 lakh people in the coming 2021 and publish their interview regarding their opinion on glamourising Over Work.

IF YOU ARE INTERESTED IN PARTICIPATING IN THE SAME, DO LET ME KNOW.

Do follow me on Facebook, Twitter Youtube and Instagram.

The copyright of this Article belongs exclusively to Ms. Aishwarya Sandeep. Reproduction of the same, without permission will amount to Copyright Infringement. Appropriate Legal Action under the Indian Laws will be taken.

If you would also like to contribute to my website, then do share your articles or poems at secondinnings.hr@gmail.com

In the year 2021, we wrote about 1000 Inspirational Women In India, in the year 2022, we would be featuring 5000 Start Up Stories.